Reviews
December 17, 2022
"Best dinner I’ve had in a long time. I highly recommend"
December 3, 2022
"3 couples celebrating 3 birthdays on a cold November Saturday early evening. Owner seated us in one of the small dining rooms with a fireplace roaring.. already perfect. Owner conversed congenially...we told him about birthdays...waiter arrived with water and proceeded to slice slivers of Romano cheese from a gigantic ball he had brought to the table. We ordered various dishes among us, and shared tastes with each other. Everything was delicious from the black pasta to the tuna to the ravioli to the wild boar. 3 desserts had 3 candles placed in them and the ownwer and waiters sang happy birthday with their great Italian accents (owner's voice is exceptional!)... overall experience..food, atmosphere, service...just perfect. Recommendations..if you are in a hurry..this is not your place..if you want excellent Italian food in a cozy atmopshere on a cold Winter's evening..then go early and enjoy."
November 21, 2022
"Beautifully cooked fish, I had the turbo and it was stunning. Much of the presentation was on carts and that made it wonderful for a large group. The environment felt very old world Italian. Absolutely stunning cake. I'm not a big fan of cake often finding it too dense and sweet, but this cake was angelic and had peaches. Our evening ended with amazing espresso and grappa. They even catered to picky children. Warm hosts, handsome staff, beautiful food. Truly a hidden treasure."
November 19, 2022
"We’ve been coming to Ristorante IL MONELLO since 2015! We have dined in 5 star dining all over the world and IL Monello is by far our favorite restaurant!!! Martino, the owner, and Saban is the absolute best and are like family to us. Their food is of the highest quality and cooked literally to perfection in an artful way. It’s the gem of Peapack NJ! This review is actually long overdue and we couldn’t be more thankful for this wonderful place we absolutely love!! Experience it for yourself!! ❤️"
November 16, 2022
"Amazing food, amazing hospitality. This was our second time here."